For Day 1, think about things that you can make. If you have a hobby where you make things like soap, baking, painting, or anything you can think of. Make something personalized, this will be a gift that people will really like because it is unique and something you created. Most likely you have almost if not everything you need already at home, so the only thing it will take you is time to make it. So this is a very frugal gift for you to give this holiday season.